A Comparative Analysis of System Monitoring Architecture: Evaluating Prometheus, Elk Stack, and Custom dashboards for performance and Scalability

Rahul Banerjee

Abstract: The proliferation of microservices and cloud-native architectures has rendered traditional system monitoring approaches insufficient, necessitating a paradigm shift towards comprehensive observability. This paper presents a comparative analysis of three dominant system monitoring architectures: the metrics-centric Prometheus ecosystem, the log-centric ELK (Elastic) Stack, and the flexible paradigm of Custom Dashboards, exemplified by Grafana. We conduct an architectural deep dive into each solution, evaluating their core components, data models, and ingestion mechanisms. The analysis focuses on key performance indicators, including ingestion throughput, query latency, and resource utilization, alongside a rigorous assessment of their scalability models for handling high data volumes, managing metric cardinality, and ensuring long-term data retention. Through an examination of real-world case studies and quantitative benchmarks, this paper establishes that the optimal choice of monitoring architecture is not a matter of universal superiority but a strategic decision contingent on an organization's primary telemetry signals, operational maturity, and specific scalability challenges. Prometheus excels in real-time, high-frequency metric analysis and alerting within dynamic environments, whereas the ELK Stack provides unparalleled capabilities for deep, full-text log analysis and security forensics. Custom Dashboards offer maximum flexibility by decoupling the visualization layer from the data backend, enabling hybrid solutions but demanding greater engineering investment. This paper concludes with a decision-making framework to guide architects and engineers in selecting the most suitable monitoring strategy for their distributed systems and a forward-looking perspective on emerging technologies like OpenTelemetry and eBPF that are reshaping the observability landscape.

Keywords: System monitoring, observability, Prometheus, ELK Stack, Grafana, custom dashboards, performance metrics, scalability

How to Cite?: Rahul Banerjee, "A Comparative Analysis of System Monitoring Architecture: Evaluating Prometheus, Elk Stack, and Custom dashboards for performance and Scalability", Volume 14 Issue 9, September 2025, International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), Pages: 916-924, https://www.ijsr.net/getabstract.php?paperid=SR25917095133, DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.21275/SR25917095133