International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)
Open Access | Fully Refereed | Peer Reviewed

ISSN: 2319-7064


Downloads: 175

Research Paper | Medical Surgical | India | Volume 7 Issue 3, March 2018


Open Mesh Repair for Ventral Hernias ? Onlay or Preperitoneal: Analysis of a Young Surgeon's Dilemma

Dr Biju K Varghese, Dr Nilanjan Roy, Dr Arpan Yadav, Dr SS Jaiswal


Abstract: Background Ventral hernias are protrusions of an abdominal viscus or a part of the viscus through an opening in the anterior abdominal wall other than the groin. Most of these patients undergo conventional open mesh repair by pre peritoneal or onlay reinforcement using a prosthetic mesh. Even though technically more difficult, preperitoneal mesh placement has been considered superior to onlay mesh. However, onlay mesh placement is considered an easier and faster option, especially in a severely scarred abdominal wall. Methods All patients with ventral hernias who underwent open mesh repair by onlay or preperitoneal prosthetic (polypropylene) mesh over a period of 18 months at a tertiary care teaching hospital were included in the study. Choice of mesh placement was based on the surgeons decision at the time of surgery. They were observed for early complications like seroma formation and infection, and late complications like chronic pain and recurrence. Results 103 out of 121 patients who underwent open surgery for ventral hernias were available for follow up at the end of two years.52 patients had undergone onlay mesh repair and 51 had undergone preperitoneal repair.44 were male and 59 were female, with age ranging from 24 to 83 years. The defects ranged from 2.5 cm to 8 cm in maximal diameter. In contrast to 13 out of 51 patients of onlay repair, only 4 out of 52 patients of preperitoneal repair had at least one of the complications studied (p value = 0.031) However, there was no statistically significant difference in the incidence of long term complications of recurrence and chronic pain between the onlay and preperitoneal mesh groups. Conclusion Though onlay mesh repair has higher overall complication rates compared to preperitoneal repair, the long term outcomes are not significantly different. Whenever possible, preperitoneal mesh repair should be carried out for ventral hernias. However, onlay repair being technically easier, can be considered as a safe and appropriate option in case of technical difficulty in dissecting safe and sufficient preperitoneal space in scarred abdominal walls or when surgical expertise to do the same is not available.


Keywords: Ventral hernia, polypropylene mesh repair, complications, recurrence


Edition: Volume 7 Issue 3, March 2018,


Pages: 33 - 37


How to Cite this Article?

Dr Biju K Varghese, Dr Nilanjan Roy, Dr Arpan Yadav, Dr SS Jaiswal, "Open Mesh Repair for Ventral Hernias ? Onlay or Preperitoneal: Analysis of a Young Surgeon's Dilemma", International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), https://www.ijsr.net/get_abstract.php?paper_id=ART2018483, Volume 7 Issue 3, March 2018, 33 - 37

How to Share this Article?

Enter Your Email Address


Similar Articles with Keyword 'Ventral hernia'

Downloads: 124

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 9 Issue 2, February 2020

Pages: 659 - 661

Negative Pressure Wound Therapy in an Infected Ventral Meshplasty Cases

Avinash Gonnade, Girish Bakhshi, Dinesh Pawar, Jessicka Shah, Geoffrey Kharmutee, Shriya

Share this Article

Downloads: 126

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 8 Issue 12, December 2019

Pages: 1538 - 1542

Postoperative Pain after Laparoscopic Ventral Hernia Repair: A Prospective Comparison of Sutures versus Tackers

Dr. Madhushankar.L, Dr. Amrith Preetam Panda

Share this Article

Similar Articles with Keyword 'complications'

Downloads: 1

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, Saudi Arabia, Volume 10 Issue 7, July 2021

Pages: 921 - 928

Attitude and Scope of Practice of Minor Surgical Procedures among PHC Physicians in Dammam, Alkhobarand Al-Qatif Cities

Zahra AlHubail, Fatimah Alnemer, Dr. Ammr Bamana

Share this Article

Downloads: 1

Informative Article, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 10 Issue 7, July 2021

Pages: 1062 - 1066

To Study the Effectiveness of Pre-Operative Care Bundle on Post-Operative Outcome among Adult Patient Undergoing Cardiac Surgeries in Selected Hospital

Abhilasha Valmik Gaidhani

Share this Article

Similar Articles with Keyword 'recurrence'

Downloads: 2 | Weekly Hits: ⮙1 | Monthly Hits: ⮙2

Review Papers, Medical Surgical, Indonesia, Volume 10 Issue 10, October 2021

Pages: 374 - 377

Thyroglossal Duct Cyst: A Literature Review

Ni Putu Ruspata Bhyantari

Share this Article

Downloads: 90

Comparative Studies, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 8 Issue 12, December 2019

Pages: 1640 - 1642

Comparative Study of Results of Stoppas Repair Vs Lichensteins Meshplasty in the Management of Inguinal Hernia

Dr Arun Mane, Dr Aditya Phadke, Dr Yash Gurjar, Dr Tushar Karwat, Dr Revannath Yenage

Share this Article

Similar Articles with Keyword 'Ventral'

Downloads: 124

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 9 Issue 2, February 2020

Pages: 659 - 661

Negative Pressure Wound Therapy in an Infected Ventral Meshplasty Cases

Avinash Gonnade, Girish Bakhshi, Dinesh Pawar, Jessicka Shah, Geoffrey Kharmutee, Shriya

Share this Article

Downloads: 126

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 8 Issue 12, December 2019

Pages: 1538 - 1542

Postoperative Pain after Laparoscopic Ventral Hernia Repair: A Prospective Comparison of Sutures versus Tackers

Dr. Madhushankar.L, Dr. Amrith Preetam Panda

Share this Article

Similar Articles with Keyword 'hernia'

Downloads: 2

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 10 Issue 6, June 2021

Pages: 88 - 90

Case Report: Late Presentation of a Case of Traumatic Left Sided Diaphragmatic Hernia

Rajendra Shinde, Sanjeev Kumar

Share this Article

Downloads: 67

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 9 Issue 12, December 2020

Pages: 1545 - 1547

Comparative Study of Mesh Fixation versus Non Fixation in Laparoscopic Inguinal Hernia Repair (TEP/TAPP)

Dr. Surendra Pathak, Dr. SP Hariram Krishna

Share this Article

Similar Articles with Keyword 'polypropylene'

Downloads: 133

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 8 Issue 3, March 2019

Pages: 1418 - 1422

A Prospective Comparative Study of Open Inguinal Hernia Repair: Self Gripping Mesh Vs Standard Polypropylene Mesh

Sharath Chandra B.J, Divakar S. R, Dandeboyina Sreenivas, Sumith.S Deep

Share this Article

Downloads: 155

Case Studies, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 6 Issue 1, January 2017

Pages: 476 - 482

Outcome of Mass Abdominal Fascial Closure in Midline Laparotomies: A Clinical Study at AVBRH

Dr Mazhar Aslam Dodhia, Dr Raju Kamlakarrao Shinde

Share this Article

Similar Articles with Keyword 'mesh'

Downloads: 67

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 9 Issue 12, December 2020

Pages: 1545 - 1547

Comparative Study of Mesh Fixation versus Non Fixation in Laparoscopic Inguinal Hernia Repair (TEP/TAPP)

Dr. Surendra Pathak, Dr. SP Hariram Krishna

Share this Article

Downloads: 90

Comparative Studies, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 8 Issue 12, December 2019

Pages: 1640 - 1642

Comparative Study of Results of Stoppas Repair Vs Lichensteins Meshplasty in the Management of Inguinal Hernia

Dr Arun Mane, Dr Aditya Phadke, Dr Yash Gurjar, Dr Tushar Karwat, Dr Revannath Yenage

Share this Article

Similar Articles with Keyword 'repair'

Downloads: 67

Research Paper, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 9 Issue 12, December 2020

Pages: 1545 - 1547

Comparative Study of Mesh Fixation versus Non Fixation in Laparoscopic Inguinal Hernia Repair (TEP/TAPP)

Dr. Surendra Pathak, Dr. SP Hariram Krishna

Share this Article

Downloads: 90

Comparative Studies, Medical Surgical, India, Volume 8 Issue 12, December 2019

Pages: 1640 - 1642

Comparative Study of Results of Stoppas Repair Vs Lichensteins Meshplasty in the Management of Inguinal Hernia

Dr Arun Mane, Dr Aditya Phadke, Dr Yash Gurjar, Dr Tushar Karwat, Dr Revannath Yenage

Share this Article
Top