Research Paper | Education Management | Indonesia | Volume 5 Issue 8, August 2016
The Effects of Direct and Indirect Error CorrectionFeedback and Students? Attitudes on The Quality of Junior High School Students? Paragraph Writing
Ahmad Sabarudin, I Wayan Ardhana, I Nyoman Sudana Degeng, Punaji Setyosari
This study was in the secondary school context in Indonesia. English is a compulsory subject in secondary school and taught as a foreign language (EFL) in Indonesia. Improving students writing ability is still a big problem for teachers. Teachers had to find the best way to improve students writing ability. Instead of ongoing controversy on the effectiveness of error correction by some researchers (Kepner, 1991, Truscott, 1999), this study was designed to investigate two types of written error correction feedback (direct versus indirect) and two types of students attitudes (positive versus negative) on students paragraph writing quality. Quality of paragraph writing was defined as the degree to which students paragraph writing met the acceptable characteristics of a good writing in term of contents, organization, vocabulary, language use, and mechanics. Seventy two secondary school students were involved in the research to write and revise paragraphs. In the direct error correction feedback condition, errors made by students were corrected and the right forms were provided by teacher next to or above the original errors. Students rewrote the drafts to make revision of the paragraphs. In the indirect error correction feedback condition, errors made by students were underlined and given codes by teacher. Students make revision of the paragraphs based on teachers feedback given. The research data were collected through pre-test and post-test and analyzed using analysis of variants through SPSS 20.0 Windows program. Results indicated that the group receiving indirect feedback performed significantly better than the group receiving direct feedback on the quality of their writing. The results also revealed that students having positive attitude toward English lesson outperformed those having negative one. Possible reasons for these findings and suggestions for future research were discussed.
Keywords: direct/indirect feedback, students attitude, paragraph writing quality
Edition: Volume 5 Issue 8, August 2016
Pages: 1780 - 1784
How to Cite this Article?
Ahmad Sabarudin, I Wayan Ardhana, I Nyoman Sudana Degeng, Punaji Setyosari, "The Effects of Direct and Indirect Error CorrectionFeedback and Students? Attitudes on The Quality of Junior High School Students? Paragraph Writing", International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), https://www.ijsr.net/search_index_results_paperid.php?id=ART20161237, Volume 5 Issue 8, August 2016, 1780 - 1784
Similar Articles with Keyword 'students attitude'
A Study & Survey of B.Ed. Students Attitude towards Using Internet
Amit Kumar Sharma, Rekha Pyase, Sapna Jain
Students Attitude towards Distance Learning at Al-Quds Open University/ Tulkarem Educational Region
Ahmed Awad Amin Mahmoud / Raba?
Similar Articles with Keyword 'feedback'
Professional Development in the Workplace: Key to Sustainable Growth
Ricky S. Yabo
Rethinking Automated Essay Scoring Solutions for Frontline Academics
Kennedy A. Osakwe, Kunle Ola, Pete Omotosho
Similar Articles with Keyword 'students'
Investigative-Action Practices in Science Teaching during the Supervised Internship at the Goiano Federal Institute
Felipe Torres Da Silva, Rosenilde Nogueira Paniago, Prof. Suzana Maria Loures de Oliveira Marcionilio, Celso Martins Belisario, Calixto Junior De Souza, Patrcia Gouvea Nunes, Simone de Sousa Moraes
The Effect of Using GeoGebra in Geometric Construction of Grade 7 Students
Dr. Sanaa Shehayeb, Mohammad Anouti, Mohammad Akkawi
Similar Articles with Keyword 'attitude'
Educational Values in the QURAN
Dr. Fachrurazi, MM
Effect of Biology Teachers Domain-Specific Beliefs about the Subject on the Integration of Technology in Instruction in Secondary Schools in Kenya
Dorcas Nelima Wamukota, Dr Edwin Masibo, Dr. Robert Nyukuri
Similar Articles with Keyword 'paragraph'
Students Ability in Developing the Paragraphs of Argumentative Essay
Riyen Permata, Hamzah
Reflection on the Use of Foreign Language Courses in Engineering, Technology and Science Teaching: Experience in Lebanese Universities
Marie-Therese Saliba, Randa Saliba Chidiac
Similar Articles with Keyword 'writing'
Teachers Perception of EFL Students Poor Writing Skills: The Challenges, Causes, and Remedies
The Reader's Response to Islamic Novel in the Classroom
Ahmad Husin; Wahyudi Siswanto; AH. Rofi'uddin; Heri Suwignyo
Similar Articles with Keyword 'quality'
A Study of Teachers Motivation and Academic Coordinators Leadership Practice: The Relationship to Vision, Inspirational Motivation, Intellectual Stimulation, Supportive Leadership and Personal Recognition
Genevieve M. Gepitulan
An Investigation into the State of Disaster and Safety Preparedness in Schools in Kenya
Simiyu Kisurulia, Dorcas Katiambo, George Akolo Lutomia